The St. Augustine Record, Fla.
Bartram Trail High School, which made headlines earlier this year regarding its dress code, is under fire once again after 80 female students had their yearbook photos edited without their consent.
The reason? To add more clothing.
The controversy comes as the school is already embroiled in a debate over its handling of the district’s dress code, which some say is sexist and unfairly targets girls. Critics said the yearbook editing sends yet another harmful message to female students.
Adrian Bartlett is the mother of a student at Bartram Trail. She said her daughter’s yearbook picture was edited in the chest area to add more shirt coverage.
“I think it sends the message that our girls should be ashamed of their growing bodies, and I think that’s a horrible message to send out to these young girls that are going through these changes,” Bartlett said.
Also, because the edit was poorly done, it makes her body look unnatural, which has led to kids teasing her, Bartlett said. While her daughter is laughing it off, Bartlett said she is concerned.
She isn’t the only one.— Ben Ryan (@BenRyanANJax) May 20, 2021
We looked at the yearbook and after speaking with several parents and students, they all said at least 60 pictures, if not more, were photoshopped/edited.
We were given permission to use these photos. @ActionNewsJax pic.twitter.com/aTgV5XlUud
“My daughter has been hospitalized twice this school year due to the stress and pressure this past year has brought upon her, including body image issues, which she is still seeking regular treatment for,” Bartlett said in an email to The Record. “And now, the school has made a decision that is now drawing attention to her body in a negative way. It sends the message that our young girls should be ashamed of their naturally growing bodies.”
According to Christina Langston, school district spokeswoman, the school’s yearbook coordinator, Anne Irwin, who is a teacher, decided that the photos were out of dress code and did some of the editing.
Parents disagree, saying the students were not out of dress code.
Irwin declined to comment for this story, according to Langston.
The high school’s website says that all student pictures in the yearbook “may be digitally adjusted” if they don’t conform to the school district’s code of conduct.
According to Langston, ” Bartram Trail High School’s previous procedure was to not include student pictures in the yearbook that they deemed in violation of the student code of conduct, so the digital alterations were a solution to make sure all students were included in the yearbook.
At this point, the school is offering refunds to any parents calling about this issue. The school is receiving feedback from parents/guardians/students on making this process better for next year.”
People have to turn in their yearbooks to get a refund, according to Langston. Photos have been edited in previous yearbooks.
Bartlett said her daughter has worn the same outfit to school regularly and has never received a violation. She said she would like to see consistency in enforcement of the dress code, and she would like to see some policies relaxed.
Other parents pointed out that a photo of male students in swim briefs by a pool made it into the yearbook without editing.
The yearbook team did not edit any team or club photos, according to Langston.
Taryn O’Keefe has two children at Bartram Trail High School, both of whom had their photos edited. She said her daughters were not in violation of the dress code with those outfits. Also, some students are being teased because of the poor quality of the editing, she said.
O’Keefe, who is also pushing for change in the district’s dress code, plans to bring the photo-editing issue, which she described as degrading and “just more body shaming,” to the School Board.
“They’re already dealing with challenges with their peers … I think it sticks with them for their lifetime,” she said.
Lorna Bracewell, program coordinator for women’s studies at Flagler College and an assistant professor of political science, said this is one of many controversies about school dress codes and gender disparities in schools across the country.
Some parents and students are calling the policy sexist for both its wording and enforcement as more than 80% of infractions over the last three years have been issued to female students, according to data provided by district officials.
A March 26 large-scale inspection of students’ dress at Bartram Trail High School resulted in 31 students cited for issues such as the length of their skirts or exposed midriffs. All of the violations were against female students.
Bracewell said using language such as “distracting” in the dress code sends a message to young girls that there’s something inappropriate or unseemly about their bodies and that they have to compensate in some way.
“That’s a bad message. That’s a message that damages the self-esteem of young people,” she said.
Bracewell said she thinks the yearbook issue reinforces that message.
Across the country, “This is a long-established practice of policing women’s bodies and responding to women’s bodies when they are presented in public with a kind of anxiety and concern,” she said.
Bracewell suggested dress guidelines for students that would apply equally to all genders. Also, she said she thinks the existing policies are excluding gender non-conforming and transgender students.
School should be a place where kids feel welcome. Reflecting on disparate ways dress code policies are enforced will lead to more inclusive schools that feel more welcoming for students, Bracewell said.
Stephanie Fabre had a busy Friday, including talking with a representative from a national media outlet about the yearbook controversy, she said.
A photo of Fabre’s daughter was edited to cover more of her chest, and now Fabre is among the parents looking for change.
“Whether it was intentional or unintentional or not, it happened, so we’ve just go to figure out how does this happen and how to make it not happen again,” she said.
She said she went to the school’s assistant principal with her daughter and was told that the shirt she was photographed in was within dress code guidelines, she said. She said her daughter has worn the same shirt to school without issue.
Fabre said she still has a number of questions about the photo editing.
“What adult approved that?” Fabre asked. “How does that happen? Why are they allowed to be judgmental on cleavage or no cleavage? And if they are allowed to Photoshop, why aren’t you teaching them proper Photoshopping skills, and why did this teacher approve for this to go to print?”
Langston said the photos were digitally altered at Irwin’s direction.
Fabre said she was told she could get a refund if the yearbook is returned and nothing has been written in it. She said it’s unrealistic to think students haven’t already gotten their yearbooks signed.
But the bigger issue is what led to the editing in the first place. She said she doesn’t want to point blame but rather wants the school to apologize and reissue the yearbooks.
“They took a non-situation and made a situation out of it. … They’ve made these girls feel humiliated,” she said.
(c)2021 The St. Augustine Record, Fla.
Visit The St. Augustine Record, Fla. at www.staugustine.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.